Entry tags:
taking note while reading academic literature
One of the people over on the Women in Academia Support Network (on FB) asked "Hi, everyone. Could I ask you all about your note-taking [ETA: and organisational] system for your academic reading? [snip]"
Having taken the time to give her a summary of my approach (which she thanked me for as it sounded useful), I thought I would clean it up and post it here, too.
I use Scrivener, with one card for every journal article, book, etc. I have ever downloaded, read, saw a citation for in something else that I might want to take a look at, etc.
The card title is the citation as it would appear in line (Jones 2019),
The card itself starts with the full citation details.
Followed by a note to myself about why this card is here e.g. "Downloaded 2019-10-05 after seeing a scopus alert for it" or, "cited by ___, who said ___". or "Emailed to me 2016-05-04 by ____, who said "____". (In the latter two cases there is a link to the card for that person.)
Then comes a section for Topics: whee I have scrivener links to cards for every topic I think might be related to this card. Those topic cards have bullet point lists which links back to every card that relates to this topic, plus a parenthetical note that says what the article is about (specifically how it relates to this topic, so it isn't always the same parenthetical note for the same journal article on every topic card, though it can be). When I add a new topic card I also add a note saying when it was added and the fact that there may be more documents (whose cards were created before this date) that could go here.
Below topics I have a "places I cite this" list (if any), with links to the document in which I cited it. I also have a card called "things I have cited", with bullet point lists linking back to the literature cards.
Under that I finally have my reading notes, which start with a sub heading "Reading notes 2019-10-27:" followed by the notes. If the article cites another article I link to a card for that article (creating it if needed) right in the notes (and on that other card I add under the "why I have this section" a note with a link back to who cited it and what they said. The reading notes are in sedimentary order, with the most recent set of notes first. Sometimes, if I read a whole book there will be sub-cards for each chapter and its notes (and links and cross references)
To keep the cross-referenced/link everything to everything else theme going, I also have a card for the record of my reading, which is a bullet point list with date, link to the article, and which page numbers (or the word "all" if I read the whole thing), so I can always look there to see if I finished reading something or not.
If I have a pdf for the document I import it into scrivener and put it under the card for its notes (and both the notes card and the pdf will have the same author-date formatted name).
Does this all take lots of time to set up? Yes, but I have many times been grateful that my past self put this much effort in, as I had forgotten reading it till I looked at the notes and links. It is also great when I need need a citation for a given topic--rather than trusting my memory, I can just go look at the topic card and see if anything there is appropriate.
If anyone uses any tips or tricks that would be compatible with this approach, but I didn't mention it above, please to leave a note in the comments to tell me about it.
Having taken the time to give her a summary of my approach (which she thanked me for as it sounded useful), I thought I would clean it up and post it here, too.
I use Scrivener, with one card for every journal article, book, etc. I have ever downloaded, read, saw a citation for in something else that I might want to take a look at, etc.
The card title is the citation as it would appear in line (Jones 2019),
The card itself starts with the full citation details.
Followed by a note to myself about why this card is here e.g. "Downloaded 2019-10-05 after seeing a scopus alert for it" or, "cited by ___, who said ___". or "Emailed to me 2016-05-04 by ____, who said "____". (In the latter two cases there is a link to the card for that person.)
Then comes a section for Topics: whee I have scrivener links to cards for every topic I think might be related to this card. Those topic cards have bullet point lists which links back to every card that relates to this topic, plus a parenthetical note that says what the article is about (specifically how it relates to this topic, so it isn't always the same parenthetical note for the same journal article on every topic card, though it can be). When I add a new topic card I also add a note saying when it was added and the fact that there may be more documents (whose cards were created before this date) that could go here.
Below topics I have a "places I cite this" list (if any), with links to the document in which I cited it. I also have a card called "things I have cited", with bullet point lists linking back to the literature cards.
Under that I finally have my reading notes, which start with a sub heading "Reading notes 2019-10-27:" followed by the notes. If the article cites another article I link to a card for that article (creating it if needed) right in the notes (and on that other card I add under the "why I have this section" a note with a link back to who cited it and what they said. The reading notes are in sedimentary order, with the most recent set of notes first. Sometimes, if I read a whole book there will be sub-cards for each chapter and its notes (and links and cross references)
To keep the cross-referenced/link everything to everything else theme going, I also have a card for the record of my reading, which is a bullet point list with date, link to the article, and which page numbers (or the word "all" if I read the whole thing), so I can always look there to see if I finished reading something or not.
If I have a pdf for the document I import it into scrivener and put it under the card for its notes (and both the notes card and the pdf will have the same author-date formatted name).
Does this all take lots of time to set up? Yes, but I have many times been grateful that my past self put this much effort in, as I had forgotten reading it till I looked at the notes and links. It is also great when I need need a citation for a given topic--rather than trusting my memory, I can just go look at the topic card and see if anything there is appropriate.
If anyone uses any tips or tricks that would be compatible with this approach, but I didn't mention it above, please to leave a note in the comments to tell me about it.